“At the Edge of the Sea”
The Eugenic Tendencies of Transhumanism Tethered in Foucauldian Power
During the past century, the innovative landscape has become so spontaneous, so consequential, and so potentially rampant that a singular advancement holds the power to shape the future of humanity. Artificial intelligence (AI) and genetic engineering have enabled the possibility to artificially enhance the human body, blurring the lines between human and machine. Springing from this burst in technological advancement, a new philosophical movement has emerged: Transhumanism promotes the enhancement of the human condition and physical organism through advanced technology (Bostrom, 2003). The technocentric transhumanists aim to achieve humanity’s next evolutionary state unaccompanied by mother nature — terminating the current condition of humanity untouched by the machine. In the last sentence of The Order of Things, philosopher and historian Michel Foucault famously wrote that one day “man would be erased, like a face drawn in the sand at the edge of the sea” (374). In the wake of this swept-away face, the transhumanists aim to draw a new picture: an artificially enhanced human. At the crux of transhumanism lie the motivational underpinnings of a eugenics project that employs Foucauldian machinations of power — wherein biopower and sovereign power are not antithetical but liaise with one another to produce new forms of life and death.
Philosopher Nick Bostrom, arguably the world’s leading transhumanist and director of Oxford’s Future of Humanity Institute, hopes that through advanced technology and science, “we shall eventually manage to become post-human, beings with vastly greater capacities than present human beings have.” In this utopian pursuit of enhancement, humans will transcend their biological limitations by obtaining “considerable increased life expectancy, intelligence, health, memory, and emotional sensitivity” (Bostrom, 2003). Every aspect of the human condition will be artificially tailored to augment the technologically driven image of perfection. This doctrine of artificial enhancement is best exemplified through a recent technological invention that bridges the human and the computer: Elon Musk’s Neuralink is developing the “Link” — an invasive brain implant with a brain-computer interface that was initially intended to “help people with paralysis regain independence through the control of computers and mobile devices” (“Applications”). This innovation, however, is a clear gateway into how novel brain-computer interfaces can promote the societal adoption towards the post-human. In the service of vitality, this concerted effort to alter the body and achieve the post-human across populations is continuous with the Foucauldian notion of biopower.
To understand how the Foucauldian machinations of power operate within transhumanism, it is salient to elucidate how transhumanists interpret the construct of the body. In Foucauldian fashion, the body is a discursively constructed image in relation to society’s established pendulum of power. With that preface in mind, transhumanists view the current state of the body as a disability that hampers the potential of humanity by means of its biological determinism. Thus, the disability of the human body is the impetus for the transhumanist ambitions of enhancement. In her commentary on The Bioethics of Enhancement: Transhumanism, Disability, and Biopolitics, philosopher Shelley Tremain postulates that “risk is central to the construction of disability as the spectre of transhumanism’s utopian vision for a future in which life is extended and death is postponed, if not overcome” (Tremain, 2019). As such, this disability of the body becomes framed as a risk to society that must be eradicated through enhancement.
In broad strokes, Foucauldian biopower is masked by the transhumanist pursuit of enhancing the human condition and engendering vitality. In The History of Sexuality, Foucault described biopower as the “power bent on generating forces, making them grow, and ordering them, rather than one dedicated to impending them, making them submit, or destroying them” (HS, 136). And interpreting power as a productive force, rather than a mere repressive agent, is a sine qua non for understanding Foucault’s oeuvre. This life-enhancing power operates to exert “a positive influence on life, that endeavors to administer, optimize, and multiply it, subjecting it to precise controls and comprehensive regulations” (HS, 137). Biopower’s meticulous management of life — its quality, duration, enhancement, optimization, and renewal — exists within the transhumanist ambition to have vast populations merge the human and the machine through the adoption of this idealized post-human. Scholars of philosophy Vernon Cisney and Nicolae Morar not only agree with the assertion that the “human body comes to be seen as a machine” but also posit that biopower works in the favor of “industrial capitalism” (Cisney et. Morar, 2016). The enhancement of the body by means of intermingling the human and the machine will effectively increase the utility of each productive member of society, promoting a capitalistic utopian future. As such, this life-producing biopower is intended to be exerted on populations at large.
On the contrary, sovereign power is the coercive counterpart to biopower: In his lecture at the Collège de France, Foucault defines sovereign power as “the right of the sword,” that is, the power to kill (SMBD). Within the framework of transhumanism, sovereign power takes shape through the desire to “kill” the current biological state of humanity. Although biopower and sovereign power are traditionally interpreted as two antithetical forces of power, transhumanism employs these two powers to collaborate in achieving the same glorified state of posthumanism. In The Bioethics of Enhancement: Transhumanism, Disability, and Biopolitics, Professor Melinda Hall affirms this notion by remarking that biopower and sovereign power “are layered together rather than neatly divided in history. This means that sovereign power, the taking of life, must find expression within the regime of biopower” (Hall, xvii). Hall further clarifies their collaborative coexistence by expounding that sovereign power asserts itself within biopower through a “death drive” which produces a “break between what must live and what must die.” Thus, transhumanism exercises these Foucauldian mechanisms of power to promote the post-human future and kill the disabled state of humanity at present.
Hemmed in the racist nature of the Foucauldian powers, transhumanism echoes the blatant motivational underpinnings of a species-wide eugenics project. Hall posits that this “death drive” operating within biopower takes the form of racism: “The racism at the heart of biopower focuses on the body; it treats the body it discovers as abnormal through the logic of calculation and comparison, and then situates that body as a risk for the population” (Hall, xvii). This racism against the abnormal dwells at the core of transhumanism and their pursuit of uniform enhancement. Further, Hall argues that “enhancement strategies and transhumanism seem to depend on the elimination of difference — written as deviance — from the human community” (Hall, 72). If the abnormal and, in this case, the current condition of the human body are not enhanced or eliminated, the enhancement of individuals becomes under threat. Thus, the transhumanist enhancer poses the following ultimatum: Unless the entire human species is enhanced, I cannot enjoy my enhancement nor achieve a state of evolutionary satisfaction. This transhumanist condition is identical to the ideology of eugenics.
This eugenic notion is validated by Foucault’s contention that the death of the abnormal is imperative for the birth of new life. This Foucauldian rationale runs as follows: “the more inferior species die out, the more abnormal individuals are eliminated, the fewer degenerates there will be in the species as a whole, and the more I — as pieces rather than individual — can live, the stronger I will be, the more vigorous I will be. I will be able to proliferate” (255). Hence, the vitality of one’s life has a direct relationship with the disappearance of another. Although this explanation follows the basic argument of evolution, humanity and the pursuit of the post-human is in the proverbial driver’s seat of progression, not the rough and random tides of mother nature. Furthermore, Hall depicts this conditional relationship through positive and negative eugenics: “Transhumanism repeatedly treats the two as co-extensive: to rid the world of disability is to enhance the human being — enhancement seems to require the rejection of disability and embodiment as risk and limitation” (Hall, 23). Here, Hall uses positive and negative eugenics in the same fashion as how Foucault explicates the binary between biopower and sovereign power.
The death of the human at present and the ubiquitous adoption of the post-human as our next evolutionary state could have the potential to lead us to this utopian promise land. However, it is important to address transhumanism’s many shortcomings that could otherwise lead humanity to a dystopian nightmare, ripe with inequality and injustice. The adoption of this philosophical ideology and the transhumanist augmentation of the post-human will inevitably lead to intensified disparities. Although enhancing the flawed nature of the human body may sound compelling, intervening in the natural lottery of life will produce grave consequences: These treatments — which include genetic editing, brain-computer interface integration, AI-driven intelligence, among other capital-intensive enhancements — will be extremely expensive and only available to the most affluent demographic of society. Thus, society will devolve into a state wherein not only economic and social disparities will heighten but also a disruptive genetic disparity will be introduced. Henceforth, it is evident that the Foucauldian machinations of power yield the influence to ignite eugenics projects and shape the future evolution of humanity.
Works Cited
“Applications,” Neuralink, https://neuralink.com/applications/.
Bostrom, Nick. “Human Genetic Enhancements: A Transhumanist Perspective.” Journal of Value Inquiry, 2003.
Cisney, Vernon W., and Nicolae Morar. Biopower: Foucault and Beyond. The University of Chicago Press, 2016.
Foucault, Michel. The Order of Things: An Archaeology of the Human Sciences. Routledge, 2010.
Foucault, Michel. The History of Sexuality: An Introduction. Vintage Books, 1990.
Foucault, Michel. “Society Must Be Defended: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1975-1976.
Hall, Melinda. The Bioethics of Enhancement: Transhumanism, Disability, and Biopolitics. Lanham, MD, 2016.
Tremain, Shelley. “Commemorating Fouacault I: Symposium on Hall’s The Bioethics of Enhancement.” BIOPOLITICAL PHILOSOPHY, 25 JUNE 2019, https://biopoliticalphilosophy.com/2019/06/25/commemorating-foucault-i-symposium-on-halls-the-bioethics-of-enhancement/.